Dabar populiaru
Published: 17 june 2013 17:43

Jonas Grinevičius: What Is Art And Are Video Games Part Of It?

Kompiuteriniai žaidimai
„Reuters“/„Scanpix“ nuotr. / Consumers of art?

Are video games a form of art? This question arises in a world of rapid technological development, a world which no longer has a clear awareness of aesthetics, impact and cultural legacy.

Many find it distasteful to even consider something created from lines of code as being thought of as art. Others accept video games as an evolution of cultural expression – one that involves the viewer in a personal exploration of concepts.

If galleries can host interactive installations that are dubbed “art”, why shouldn’t video games – a form of media built around interaction as the core idea – be called art as well?

It would appear that the author’s intent plays a large role in how their creation is perceived. The audience would be more likely to recognize something as art, if they knew it was designed as such from the beginning.

However, this raises a further query: would a video game that objectively has the elements of an artistic piece still be labeled as art, even if it was created with no such purpose in mind? Is it possible to accidentally create art?

If art is defined as skillful procedure, a process of competent creation, then the answer is “yes.”  In this case, anything that clearly required a large amount of skill to be produced should be referred to as art, since there is a close association in the human mind between the quality of a result and the amount of effort spent in achieving it.

Video games as a category of media would appear to be art, since they cannot avoid having some sort of (un)intended artistic elements, use interaction as a means to draw the audience into an aesthetic adventure into someone else’s mind.

Does this make things any less muddled? Unfortunately, no. A whole slew of questions beg to be answered. What is the skill barrier separating art from non-art? Who decides where the barrier is? Is the skill barrier perceived subjectively, or is there an objective way to measure it? How can we be sure that any declaration of a creation being art is accurate? What if someone manages to produce an aesthetically pleasing piece without much (or even – any) effort?

Since it is hard to determine what does and what does not constitute art, when considering the intention behind the design and the skill associated with it, what criteria should be used to classify art? What form does Occam’s Razor take in this situation?  

Art being linked to aesthetic pleasure runs into a very solid obstacle: everyone’s tastes differ and they change with time, experience and conditioning.

The average score of society’s opinion of what is pleasing to behold would not work either. This lowest common denominator approach would be representing only a fraction of what is found to be appealing and would embody only creations of moderate quality.

What about art as usefulness and direct value? Contributing to society isn’t exactly the purpose of art, if one would think about this intuitively.

It would seem that art created for its own sake, without any pragmatism in mind, would be a more precise interpretation. Since video games are created with the primary intention of allowing others to experience a different world, to provide a form of escapism from reality, they seem to fit this definition: enjoyment of video games, just like enjoyment gained from reading a book or watching a film is not useful in any tangible manner.

In this case, art would be created to express the author’s emotions, thoughts and imagination. Is this not a sufficiently simple – and at the same time exceptionally complex – criterion for calling something art?

If so, “art” becomes a category encompassing a very wide range of activities and gives rise to distinguishing between good and bad art (and everything in between and beyond the two categories) – “Art” and “art”, so to speak.

It is this particular distinction about the quality of art that can use the previously mentioned qualifications – intention, level of skill, aesthetic pleasure – to determine what kind of cultural impact a piece would have.

Video games franchises such as Call of Duty or Halo are popular and widely accepted, but do they leave an impact in the hearts and mind of the public as deep as Bastion and Portal?

Great art requires lasting impressions that force the audience to think, to reconsider biases and to see the world from someone else’s viewpoint. It is about sharing ideals, broadening horizons and inspiring people to think about something new.

As Banksy says, “Art should comfort the disturbed and disturb the comfortable.” In a manner of speaking, being an artist means being a rebel, since it requires endless originality and novel means of presentation.

Ironically, video games would be the perfect candidate for art: they are a relatively new form of expression and are radically challenging the accepted formula of guided versus interactive media.

Video games as a category of media would appear to be art, since they cannot avoid having some sort of (un)intended artistic elements, use interaction as a means to draw the audience into an aesthetic adventure into someone else’s mind.

Does this mean that all video games are great art? Obviously not. Recognizing a new form of expression as being relevant to society does not immediately make it the height of culture.

Hopefully, once the discussion about art and video games simmers down (perhaps with the arrival of another pretentious medium), everyone can return to what is important – aiming for the highest quality of thought, creation and aesthetics.

Report mistake

Successfully sent

Thank you

Naujienos

Aktualu

Afganistano moterys, neįveikusios dviejų pirštų nekaltybės testo, vis dar kalinamos su žudikėmis

Aktualu

15min paaiškina: kaip Lietuvoje vyks prekyba vaistais su kanapėmis?

Pasaulis kišenėje

Rudens magija: 5 vietos Vilniuje, kurias fotografas rekomenduoja puikioms nuotraukoms

Verslas

Ingrida Šimonytė: čia dar vienas „rekordinis“ biudžetas

Kultūra

Paskelbtas prestižinės „Man Booker“ premijos laureatas

„Ginčas“: kaip FIBA vadovo netektis pakeis pasaulio krepšinį?

Verslas

Obuolių supirkėjai: derlius geras, bet vaisiai – per pigūs

Sportas

J.Lowo košmaras tęsiasi: Vokietija Paryžiuje krito prieš planetos čempionus

Gyvenimas

Šeima trejus metus gyvena tik viena diena: Elzė gimė su sindromu, su kuriuo išgyvena tik vienetai

15min iš Stambulo 24sek

Prieš mūšį su „Anadolu Efes“ – geros žinios žalgiriečių stovykloje

Vardai

Ypatingą šou su scenos kolegomis surengęs Radžis: „Esu pirmas čigoniukas, koncertuojantis arenose“

Išankstinė Kanų liūtų reklamų peržiūra su 15min

24sek

Čempionų lyga: „Lietkabelis“ krito Izraelyje ir prarado D.Tarolį

Gazas

Mįslė: kaip pervažiuoti iš šalies, kurioje eismas vyksta kaire puse, į valstybę, kurioje automobiliai juda dešine?

Vardai

Marius Jovaiša iškilmingai pristatė antrą „Neregėtą Lietuvą“: fotografą sveikino garbūs svečiai

Vardai

Ieva Narkutė pristatė albumą ir papasakojo apie puodelį kavos, kuris baigėsi labai netikėtai

Vardai

Koncerte „Nekaltinu savo likimo“ Radžį sveikino garsūs bičiuliai ir jo gerbėja Raisa Šarkienė

Verslas

Konkursas „Už darnią plėtrą“: prie jūros kviečiantys apartamentai Kuršių nerijoje

24sek

L.Lekavičius ir „Panathinaikos“ krito Bavarijoje

Gyvenimas

Pienligė – ne tik moterų, bet ir vyrų liga

Naujienos

Aktualu

Afganistano moterys, neįveikusios dviejų pirštų nekaltybės testo, vis dar kalinamos su žudikėmis

Aktualu

15min paaiškina: kaip Lietuvoje vyks prekyba vaistais su kanapėmis?

Pasaulis kišenėje

Rudens magija: 5 vietos Vilniuje, kurias fotografas rekomenduoja puikioms nuotraukoms

Verslas

Ingrida Šimonytė: čia dar vienas „rekordinis“ biudžetas

Kultūra

Paskelbtas prestižinės „Man Booker“ premijos laureatas

„Ginčas“: kaip FIBA vadovo netektis pakeis pasaulio krepšinį?

Verslas

Obuolių supirkėjai: derlius geras, bet vaisiai – per pigūs

Sportas

J.Lowo košmaras tęsiasi: Vokietija Paryžiuje krito prieš planetos čempionus

Gyvenimas

Šeima trejus metus gyvena tik viena diena: Elzė gimė su sindromu, su kuriuo išgyvena tik vienetai

15min iš Stambulo 24sek

Prieš mūšį su „Anadolu Efes“ – geros žinios žalgiriečių stovykloje

Vardai

Ypatingą šou su scenos kolegomis surengęs Radžis: „Esu pirmas čigoniukas, koncertuojantis arenose“

Verslas

Konkursas „Už darnią plėtrą“: prie jūros kviečiantys apartamentai Kuršių nerijoje

24sek

L.Lekavičius ir „Panathinaikos“ krito Bavarijoje

Gyvenimas

Pienligė – ne tik moterų, bet ir vyrų liga

24sek

M.Kalnietis buvo rezultatyviausias, o ASVEL laimėjo

Gyvenimas

Viskas, ką turite žinoti apie seksą po persileidimo

24sek

Čekijoje – penki J.Mačiulio tritaškiai ir AEK triumfas po dviejų pratęsimų

Mokslas.IT

Tyrimas: 2018-aisiais smarkiai traukėsi Šveicarijos ledynai

15min iš Londono Mokslas.IT

E.Musko idėja virto serialu: „National Geographic“ parodė pirmą mirtį Marse ir pirmą gimusį kūdikį

24sek

Eurolyga: sunki CSKA pergalė ir sublizgėjęs „Daruššafaka“ latvis

Gera keliauti kartu

Video

32:10
01:02
01:11

BALTIJOS MAISTO IR GĖRIMŲ PARODA „BAF“ 2018

Įkvėpk daugiau gyvenimo

Nacionalinis sveikatos egzaminas 2018